Why Self-Care Feels So Hard: A Therapist’s Perspective on Early Adaptations, Emotional Avoidance, and Identity
Even when we understand that self-care matters, it can feel nearly impossible to act on that knowledge. You might know how helpful a good meal, restful sleep, or even a glass of water could be, yet find yourself frozen, avoidant, or emotionally shut down in the face of those very tasks.
If this is your experience, you’re not failing. You’re not broken. And you’re not the only one.
Therapists often work with people who are deeply resourced, insightful, and self-aware. And still, they struggle profoundly with basic self-tending. The reasons for that struggle are not moral or motivational. They are survival-based.
What You’ll Learn in This Post:
Why early experiences shape your self-care habits
How emotional avoidance makes daily tasks feel overwhelming
How identity beliefs create internal conflict around tending to your needs
Therapist-informed practices to meet yourself with more care
Why Struggling With Self-Care Is More Common Than You Think
Before we go any further: struggling with self-care is not a character flaw.
It’s not about laziness. It’s not about lack of discipline. It’s not about choosing suffering. More often, it’s a sign that your nervous system is doing exactly what it learned to do under threat. Prioritize survival over comfort. Numb instead of feel. Freeze rather than risk vulnerability.
If brushing your teeth, feeding yourself, or asking for help feels impossible: it makes sense. Let’s start by removing shame from the conversation so healing has a place to land.
How Early Adaptations Affect Self-Care Habits
If your early environment taught you that your needs were inconvenient, shameful, or even dangerous, you may have developed strategies to suppress them. These weren’t flaws. They were brilliant adaptations.
Maybe needing comfort resulted in punishment or rejection
Maybe expressing hunger, sadness, or fatigue overwhelmed the caregivers around you
Maybe there was simply no one attuned enough to notice what you needed
In response, your system did the only thing it could: it minimized your needs. It learned to delay, dismiss, or completely bypass them.
Even now, those patterns may still run the show.
Instead of forcing action, try witnessing the pattern.
Micro-noticing: Set a gentle reminder once a day that simply asks: “What have I not noticed I need?” You don’t need to respond to the need. Just notice without judgment.
A moment of presence: When you feel the urge to push through or dismiss your needs, pause. Place one hand on your body. Say: “You learned this so early. No wonder it’s still here.”
You’re not fixing it. You’re honouring the wisdom of your earliest survival strategies.
(Explore how Somatic Therapy in Surrey supports nervous system reconnection.)
Self-Care and Emotional Avoidance: Why It Feels Unsafe
For many people, self-care isn’t neutral. It brings up grief, loneliness, and memory.
Brushing your teeth at night might seem like a small thing, but it can carry a quiet ache: I’m doing this alone again.
Cooking a meal might stir the sadness of being uncared for.
Resting might awaken guilt if stillness was never safe.
What looks like procrastination is often your nervous system shielding you from emotional overwhelm.
Instead of pushing through the resistance, sit beside it.
Soften the environment: Light a candle. Choose a warm cloth. Use music that reminds you of someone steady. Let your surroundings co-regulate you.
Name the ache gently: If something feels too heavy to do, ask: “Is this about the task, or the feeling that comes with it?” You don’t need to fix it. Just let it be known.
You’re not avoiding a task. You’re protecting something tender. That deserves care, not shame.
“This isn’t about willpower. It’s about safety.”
When Self-Care Doesn’t Match Your Identity: Therapist Insights
Sometimes, we resist self-care because it disrupts our identity.
If you’ve always been the responsible one, the achiever, the one who manages chaos, rest may feel incompatible with who you believe yourself to be.
If you’ve been valued for your caregiving, independence, or grit, letting yourself receive might feel undeserved or wrong.
Your system may quietly ask: “Who am I if I’m not pushing through?”
Instead of changing your identity, let it expand. Slowly.
Use soft bridging language: Instead of “I deserve to rest,” try “Maybe it’s okay to rest tonight.” Let your language soothe, not provoke.
Let care be quiet: Choose small, nourishing acts that don’t challenge your self-concept too quickly. Brush your hair. Choose socks you like. Drink water without needing to explain why.
You don’t need to become someone else to take care of yourself. You’re just learning to care for the version of you that’s been waiting, quietly, all along.
(Read more about IFS Therapy in Surrey and internal self-identity work.)
Final Thoughts: Why Safety, Not Willpower, Shapes Self-Care
If self-care feels hard, it’s not because you’re failing. It’s because your system has protected you in powerful ways. Those protections deserve reverence.
Healing isn’t about overriding your nervous system. It’s about inviting it into something gentler.
And if you need support doing that, you’re allowed to ask. Therapy offers a place to untangle these deeper patterns without urgency or judgment.
Ready to Begin?
Fill out a New Client Form to get matched with one or more of our counsellors. If you’re ready, book a free consult or appointment today.
-
Often, the difficulty lies not in knowledge but in the body’s survival adaptations. When care felt unsafe or shameful early on, your nervous system may still respond as if tending to yourself is threatening.
-
Yes. Many people come to therapy not because they lack information, but because they need help feeling safe enough to apply it. Trauma-informed counselling can help gently unpack the deeper roots of avoidance, resistance, and shame.
-
It can be, but not always. Many people without clinical depression still struggle with daily care due to past trauma, chronic stress, or emotional overwhelm. A therapist can help clarify what’s happening in your case.
-
Changes in self-care ability can reflect burnout, trauma resurfacing, grief, or chronic stress. It doesn’t mean you’ve failed. It means your system is asking for care, not critique.
-
Choose something that doesn’t require “motivation”, a sensory reset like cold water or warm tea, a gentle movement, or a sentence like “I’m allowed to go slow.” These count. You count.
You Might Also Be Interested In:
Blogs
Services
Disclaimer: The content on this website is for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical, psychological, or mental health advice. It is not a substitute for professional care. Always consult a qualified healthcare provider for diagnosis and treatment.